Showing posts with label #F.Gregg Bemis#Lusitania. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #F.Gregg Bemis#Lusitania. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Lusitania Salvage -- Continuing Litigation Part XIII

SECOND LUSITANIA BEMIS SALVAGE CASE—Part XIII

Michael Sean Quinn*


            The first of the Bemis-Salvage cases was an English case in the Court of the Queen’s Bench Division.  In that case, Bemis prevailed in the sense that he established ownership rights for himself as opposed to—but only as opposed to--the Crown.  Now comes the next phase.  Did he establish such rights for all of the contents of the ship, or just for some of them. And was he able to block the efforts of others.  Bemis v. RMS Lusitania, 884 F.Supp. 1043 (E.D. Va. 1995) aff'd (4th Cir. 1996).

Several parties had originally been involved. Bemis settled with one of them, so there were only two left, and an entity named Fifty Fathom Ventures, Inc. was the other.  FFV’s position was roughly, “Look,  we dove[--or is it ‘dived’--] down to the ship too, granted it was in 1994 and Brmis dove down in 1982, but still. . . .” Facts about the another party, Muriel Light, more or less speaking for her late husband, play a role in the evolution of the case and in the court's considering chain of title, though I am going to ignore it.  One of the questions Bemis placed before the court was whether he could have an injunction stopping others from following his lead and making off with artifacts what were really his. So we have ownership and injunction.

 There were some procedural matters discussed in the opinion, but I am skipping all those too.  I am even skipping some of the admiralty terminology discussions. This essay is about insurance and its aftermath. 
Title by Conveyance
The Liverpool and London War Risks Insurance Association Limited insured the ship against loss from what happened. It paid Cunard for its loss under the policy and thereby acquired ownership interest and right in the vessel.  In 1967, it sold what it had to John Light (“Light”), namely,
the rights and interest in the wreck of the LUSITANIA on the understanding that it would not be salved as a whole, repaired and put into commission again, and also that the purchaser takes over all liabilities and expenses which might attach to the wreck. [Emphasis added.]

Less than three weeks later Light entered into an agreement with the publisher Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, Inc. (“HRW”), and it paid him in anticipation of a book of photographs. Light sold his rights to someone else; that someone else sold them to yet another; and eventually Bemis ended up with title to whatever it was that the insurer had conveyed. (I'm not sure whether anything happened with Light and his taking photos.)
The case discusses all this, but I will skip over it, since the insurance policy plays no role in determining title, although a letter from the insurer relating to subrogation and title transfer sent to Light does.  Still, insurance matters were not in controversy.[1]

               One of the important questions in this lawsuit was therefore what was conveyed running from the insurer to Bemis. Obviously, what it did legally convey was only what it could, legally speaking “convey." The other significant questions pertained to the law of finds and the law of salvage.  These questions all pertain to the ultimate and essential question, "What did Bemis own?"  The answer to this question begins with the question, "Were the contents that were not part of the ship, i.e., the personal property that belonged to passengers or which was cargo, abandoned?"  That issue comes first.  
Law of Finds
               What earlier cases have called “the ancient and honorable principle of ‘finders, keepers,” earlier applied to maritime property which had never been owned by anyone.  In recent times, however,  that principle has changed. Now that principle applies when an owner has abandoned his/her property. Abandonment is to be inferred if no one comes forward and claims it.  The court found that precisely that had happened and found the contents to be abandoned.
               But a problem now arises. In order to be able to be a finder and have a right of keeping, the claimant must take possession of the property and that requires that the claimant exercise “dominion or control over” the claimed property.  But except for what he had already salvaged, Bemis did not have possession over the property he claimed.  What he had salvaged was what was on the list of property involved in the Queen’s Bench case and one other item, a spoon from the the Lusitania's cargo. (I wonder how could know that it was cargo and not a utensil owned and used by Cunard, e.g., to serve passengers. Or how it could be known that it was not the personal property of one of the passengers.  Granted, people often travel without any of their spoons.)
               The next question then becomes, "Did Bemis have any type of "possession" of the personal property not part of the hull that is still at the bottom of the sea?" To possess it under these circumstances held the court, Bemis would have to have control over that property and his right to go get it does not imply possession, nor does the fact that he (and those working for and with him) have gone down two times, and a third attempt had failed. (One of those trips was a National Geographic magazine trip to get photos and videos for a TV documentary.)

Law of Salvage
               The court noted that the requirement of possession is much looser under the law of salvage than under the law of finds. Indeed, the meaning of the term “possession” appears to be quite different. Nevertheless a liberal salvage award and injunctive relief so that a claimant may have the sole right to continue salvage operations involves three elements.
               First, the property must be in “marine peril.” This court quoted as follows:  “Courts will usually find that underwater shipwrecks are in marine peril, because sunken vessels and their cargoes are in danger of being lost forever.” Second, “the salvage service must be voluntary. Third and finally, “the salvage must be successful, in whole or in part,” and the salvage process must be a continual process, though it need not be continuous.
               Although it was an odd way to put it, the court held that Bemis had not “demonstrated the requisite amount of possession over the contents to qualify for the exclusive right to salvage in the future.” He had not exercised “due diligence or continuing salvaging operations[.]” (And the court spends a couple of pages describing gaps in Bemis’s salvage efforts.)
               So that was that, and I cannot find clear evidence of further efforts by Bemis since the court’s ruling, but there is some unclear evidence that there were some, at least financed by him.  At the time, Bemis’s principal opponent, FFV, was ordered by the court to turn over to him the items it had recovered. The reason was interesting.  All of those items seem to have been part of or attached to the hull (actually making they part of it); Bemis did own that by conveyance.[2] I have found no evidence that FFV continued its efforts. 
               So far as I can tell, there have been a few further attempts to visit if not salvage from the Lusitania in the last two decades.  (1) The opinion of the Fourth United States Court of Appeals which has jurisdiction over federal district courts in Virginia and which affirmed Judge Clarke’s decision noted in passing that one Polly Tapson, a Brit, and her chums, had talked about taken a “stab” at a salvage effort around 1994. She was a "big time" diver, so maybe she kept going. The Internet does not have clear evidence that her plans ever happened, even once.[3] (2) Eoin McGarry claims to a dived down to what he and Bemis call “the Old Lady” 30 times. (3) And apparently Bemis may have financed some further “visits.”[4]
               There is a completely different story floating around about Bemis’s conflicts with the government of the Republic of Ireland and most especially its National Monuments Service which apparently now has jurisdiction over the ship, since the United Nations Law of the Seas statute extended territorial waters from 3 miles to 12.[5] (The reader will remember that the Lusitania is positioned at 11.5 miles from the Irish coast.) There is a decision of the Irish Supreme Court recounting parts of this conflict,[6] but that will have to await the next Part of the blog telling that story.
              
Michael Sean Quinn, Ph.D., J.D., C.P.C.U. . . .
The Law Firms of Michael Sean Quinn and
Quinn and Quinn
                                                  1300 West Lynn Street, Suite 208
                                                              Austin, Texas 78703
                                                                  (512) 296-2594
                                                             (512) 344-9466 - Fax
                                                 E-mail:  mquinn@msquinnlaw.com





           





[1] In note 5 the District Judge, one Clarke, states this: “The Court notes that Bemis did not present any evidence covering the insurance contract between Cunard and Liverpool and London.  Therefore, the Court looks to the letter sent by Liverpool and London to Light on March 2, 1967 in an effort to determine the scope of insurance coverage.”  I conjecture that if Bemis had the policy, he would have produced it, probably as an exhibit to the Complaint. Hence, I conclude that he did not have it.  Why not? That strikes me as rather strange.  I have undertaken to lay my hands on it in various ways.  I have not, however, gone to the Clerk of the Queen’s Bench, yet and asked for it.  Shame on me.  Still if that Court does not have it, Why not?
[2]Stolley, see note 4 below,  reports that the objects FV was required to hand over to Bemis were turned over by him to an Irish museum.

[3] According to some of the questions found on the Internet, she is a bit of a mystery.  She did some videos, some photos, and led some fun expeditions. But it looks like she may have died in the early 2000s. John Chatterton may have also done some independent diving.

[4] He wants to prove that what sank the ship so fast was a munitions explosion in or near a boiler room.  That is contrary to the received view that no such thing happened. See Richard B. Stolley, Lusitania: The Epic Battle Over Its Biggest Mystery, found in a 2015 issue of FORTUNE magazine and on the Internet.
[5] The Service Bemis may not be on the best terms. Stolley describes Bemis’s reactions to it as “colorful, unsparing criticism of the country’s cultural mandarins.”  Again according to Stolley, what the Service says it is doing is protecting a historical, archeological object, a historic monument, and as a cemetery. Even Bemis’s own lawyer has said that he is a bit of a “pain in the ass” when it comes to the Service.

[6] Bemis v. Minister for the Arts, Heritage, Gaeltacht and The Islands [2007]IESC 10, [2007]3 IR 255.  The decision—3 justices with 2 writing opinions can be found on the Internet under “Supreme Court of Ireland Decisions” (So what does the word "Gaeltacht" mean? It is an Irish-language word used to denote any primarily Irish-speaking region. There is a Wikipedia articles using that word as the title, Mainly they are geographical areas in Ireland recognized by the government where a meaningful-to-significant fraction of the population speak the native language on a daily basis. That population is apparently shrinking. 

Lusitania: Salvage--Some Anyway--Part XII

Lusitania: First Bemis Salvage Case—Part XII
Michael Sean Quinn*

F. Gregg Bemis, Jr. is now an elderly, wealthy, Harvard MBA-type. He says he walked out on his executive employment  in the 1970s at the age of 51 and became a variety of different things, including several types of investors.  A little after he retired, he began diving—and having other dive with and for him. The Lusitania was one of his “targets,” and he found it.  It looks like he made three attempts at salvage. Some of all this will be described in “Lusitania: Second Bemis Salvage Case—Part XIII.

 Thereon lie three different but not separate stories. One was in the Court of the Queen’s Bench Division in England[1]; one was in the federal courts in the United States, both District Court and appellate court; and one involving a dispute with the government of the Republic of  Ireland. Nothing further will be said about Mr. Bemis himself. Superficial material about his is easily findable on the “Net,” as are several photographs.

In any case, Bemis found the Lusitania and bought it from persons who had bought it from the insurance company that had covered it.  (If a property insurer pays for a covered loss to a structure, it becomes the owner of the structure. Of course, often, it is property is totally destroyed, since it no longer exists, there is nothing to own or sell. Or is there? There is, if one counts a complete wreck as total destruction. Moreover, there may be continuing property rights somehow connected to other property rights.)

In any case, in 1982 divers working for Bemis brought up more than a few chattels (aka movable property). Some of it was actually part of the ship, which Bemis has already purchased from others who had purchased it from  London and Liverpool War Risk Associates Ltd, the company that insured the Lusitania for the loss inflicted by the U-boat perhaps among others..[2] Some of what he had brought up  was part of the ship. 
A lawsuit arose over who owned the contents that were not part of the ship.  That is the lawsuit about to be discussed. That problem will arise again in the American lawsuit.

Bemis worked out settlements with some of the folks who thought they might have rights, so in the end the lawsuit was between Bemis and people or entities he “controlled,” on one side, and the British government on the other, i.e., “the Crown.”
The decision of the court is interest reading filed with precedent running back to 1601 and legal terminology which most American’s today have never heard, e.g., “droit”[3] and “ligan”—or have heard and used only as slang, e.g., “flotsam,” “jetsam,” usually meaning some sort of junk.  Even the terms “wreck” and “derelict [ion]” have special meanings in the British vocabulary of maritime law. Pierce and Another v. Bemis and Others (Court of the Queen’s Bench, November 29, 1985).[4] (In American courts this case would be usually be cited 1 Q.B. 401 (1986).

I am going to skip all that, chocked bull of educational tid-bits though it is.   And I am going to skip summarizing the many lengthy quotes pertaining to such topics as the history of how the idea of “droit” was  thought of in history of English admiralty law, fascinating though they are too.

The  issue before the court was, in the end, really quite simple. Who had legal title to the contents brought to the surface, Bemis or the Crown. The latter claimed it at least because it had been brought within British territory after it was found. The court’s decision depended on the correct interpretation of a key British statute, The Merchant Shipping Act of 1894 (and a few subsequent amendments). (There were other, earlier maritime statutes that were discussed. I am going to skip them too.)

Interestingly the court notes that English jurisprudence treats statutory interpretation differently than does America.  This case cites the great Lord Denning in another case where he said this:

In this country we do not refer to the legislative history of an enactment as they to in the United States of America. We do not look at the explanatory memoranda which preface the Bills before Parliament. We do not have recourse to the pages of Hansard.[[5]] All that the courts can do is to take judicial notice of the previous state of the law and of other matters generally know to well-informed people.
Escoigne Properties Ltd. V. Inland Revenue Commissioners [1958] A.C. 549, 566. 

Under English practice,what is important here is that an English court’s job is to determine whether a given statute under consideration changed the previous law.  If I have understood it correctly, this means the judges must focus on earlier statutes and  judge-made law in thinking about the meaning of a new statute, and not to any extent on what the legislative body, as it were, has said to itself about what it was doing or said to others about its intent when it passed the new law.  Truth is: I think I like their system better.

            In any case, the statute said that if objects like those at issue in the Bemis case were found within Britain’s territorial waters and they were unclaimed by previous owners, they went to the Crown.  The chattels at issue in this case were not in English territorial waters, therefore--well, what? Who was to get them?

            In the end the judge said that there was no law as to the Crown having a property right in/over what is, in effect, abandoned property lost in and found in international waters.  The fact that there was not specific law about this merely entail that there is a “lacuna” in the law, as the court  called it.  But since no one can make a plausible claim to have a legal right to any of the objects and since Bemis possesses them, there are to be regarded as his.

            Under the circumstances, this strikes me as a just result, particularly since he spent a fair amount of money procuring them.  But this is not the end of the story. What about the contents not brought up and still remaining at the bottom of the sea, though only about the length of a football field down. 

As a sort of footnote is is worth reporting a magazine articles by one Richard B. Stolley, entitled LUSITANIA; THE EPIC BATTLE OVER ITS BIGGEST MYSTERY (2015) reports that the 1982 dive--Bermis's first salvage attempt--was conducted partly to determine whether an estimated $12M could be recovered if the ship were sold commercially as scrap.  Apparently Bemis had hired an independent firm to do most of the work, although he apparently did some of the diving. It ended up with a lot of the "treasure," and Bemis did not  make much. 


Michael Sean Quinn, Ph.D., J.D., C.P.C.U. . . .
The Law Firms of Michael Sean Quinn et
Quinn and Quinn
                                 1300 West Lynn Street, Suite 208
                                             Austin, Texas 78703
                                                 (512) 296-2594
                                            (512) 344-9466 - Fax
                                E-mail:  mquinn@msquinnlaw.com








[1] “The Queen's Bench Division in England and Wales today consists of the Lord Chief Justice and fourteen puisne judges, exercising original jurisdiction and also appellate jurisdiction from the county courts and other inferior courts, in practice being exercised by a division of the Queen's Bench only. Other sub-divisions include the Commercial, the Admiralty Court and the Administrative Court. The abbreviation QB (or KB) in legal citation is used in the Law Reports to denote cases heard in the Queen's (or King's) Bench Division.” I took this from as Wikipedia article, “Queen’s Bench.” Obviously, there’s lots more to say.

[2] Interestingly, it is not always clear exactly what the name of the insurer was. Some say it was a Lloyds Syndicate, and maybe it was.  However, in the American case, Bemis v. RMS Lusitania,884 F.Supp. 1042 (E. D. Va. 1915), aff’d 99 F.3d 1129 (4th Cir. 1996), the insurer is called the Liverpool and London War Risks Insurance Association Limited. Of course, one doubts that the discrepancy really matters, except. . . .

[3] OK. I’ll back down for “droit,” but only an inch or two. The term comes from the French meaning a right. In the present context, the word would be used to determine who had a property  in a lots object to which no one was making a claim based upon a property interest. In olden days, in England, it might be the Lord of the Manor, or it might be the Crown. Interestingly, the word “adroit” has the same origin. It means really skillful. My guess is that it worked this way: a person was so consistently good at something that it looked like he had a right to be able to do it.  “He can do it so well—better than absolutely everybody, or (at least) the few who have tried--and has been doing it for so long, as everyone knows, that it’s like his property so he has the right to say that it is really his.” Granted, this guess is not exactly compelling, but it would not mean that someone was simply getting things very right.  The term “maladroit” is simply the opposite of “adroit.”

[4] There may also be differences in other sorts of usages, as well. Virtually the first, if not the out-and-out first, sentence in this case reads in part as follows: “The Lusitania, a passenger liner outward bound for New York. . . .” In think in American English it would be said in virtually the opposite way, namely, “The Lusitania, a passenger liner outward bound from New York for Liverpool. . . .”

[5]“Hansard is the traditional name of the transcripts of Parliamentary Debates in Britain and many Commonwealth countries. It is named after Thomas Curson Hansard (1776–1833), a London printer and publisher, who was the first official printer to the parliament at Westminster.” Copied from a Net entry.